On My Block · NYC Politics

Small BusinessBrooklyn

A proposed business improvement district for North Williamsburg draws a lawsuit and a petition. Here is how a BID gets approved

The Northside BID would cover Grand Street to North 15th, Bedford Avenue to the river, and charge property owners for extra cleaning and safety. Council Member Lincoln Restler is backing it; the Council gets a vote before it can form.

A plan to create a business improvement district across North Williamsburg has turned into a neighborhood fight, with a petition against it and a lawsuit challenging how its vote is being run, Gothamist reported Wednesday.

Why it matters to residents: a BID adds a charge to property owners' bills to pay for extra services, such as daily trash pickup, sidewalk cleaning, public safety and streetscape projects. Owners can pass some of that cost on to commercial tenants. Once formed, a BID is hard to undo.

The proposal

According to Gothamist:

  • Name and area: the Northside Williamsburg Business Improvement District, from Grand Street to North 15th Street and from Bedford Avenue to the East River. It would be the city's 79th BID.
  • Services: extra street cleaning and daily trash pickup by a few dozen workers, public safety, plants, lighting and public art, and help for businesses.
  • Cost to owners: charges based on a property's size and assessed value, which could add hundreds or thousands of dollars a year to tax bills. No total budget was given.
  • Backers: a steering committee chaired by Ward Dennis, with the North Brooklyn Parks Alliance as a leading proponent.

Lincoln Restler, who represents the area, is co-leading the push. He called a lawsuit against it "totally frivolous and irrelevant," Gothamist reported. In March, at a Zoning Subcommittee hearing on a North Williamsburg development, Restler told the applicant the site was "within the catchment area for the new Northside business improvement district that we're working on" and asked whether the owner supported it (42:42).

The opposition

According to Gothamist:

  • A petition says the plan was developed with "the wealthiest landlords and interests" and will "prioritize privatization and profit over the community's well-being."
  • A residential property owner has sued the steering committee, its chair, the city and affiliated groups, arguing the voting began too early and departs from the city's official process.
  • Some property owners object to the new charges, and some residents see the BID as part of the neighborhood's shift toward upscale brands.

How a BID is approved

  • Owner ballots: a majority of assessed properties in the area must support it, Gothamist reported. Ballots went out in October 2025 and voting is still open, with no official deadline.
  • City review: the Department of Small Business Services decides whether to sponsor the plan and looks for "broad-based support."
  • Public review: the community board and borough president weigh in, and the Council holds a hearing and votes on the district plan and its budget.
  • The mayor gives final sign-off.

The Council also votes when an existing BID wants to raise its budget. Its Finance Committee takes up Int. 1112 on Thursday, Nov. 19, which would raise spending caps for eight BIDs, as we reported.

The Small Business Services Department told the Council in March that it oversees 78 BIDs delivering more than $216 million in services a year across nearly 300 commercial corridors (13:12).

What's next

No Council hearing on the Northside BID is scheduled. It would come only after the owner vote and city review, and after the court acts on the lawsuit.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime