On My Block · NYC Politics

HousingFinance

Three former cluster shelters in the Bronx, with 2,066 open violations, are up for a 40-year tax break to pay for gut renovations

The Finance Committee votes Thursday on full property tax exemptions for 161 apartments in Fordham and Bedford Park and 32 in Washington Heights. City staff put the Bronx break at $60 million over 40 years.

Three Bronx apartment buildings the city once rented as shelters for homeless families are in line for full property tax exemptions under resolutions before the City Council's Committee on Finance on Thursday morning, Nov. 19. A second request covers two rent-stabilized walk-ups in Washington Heights.

Why it matters to residents: tax breaks like these are how the city pays for repairs in buildings it wants to keep affordable. The Council has 120 days to approve or reject a request from the Department of Housing Preservation and Development; if it does nothing, the exemption is deemed approved, according to the Finance Division's committee report.

Fordham Bedford Cluster Phase 3 (Bronx)

The project, LU 159, covers three buildings with 161 apartments, including three superintendent units, and six storefronts, in Council Districts 14 and 15. According to the Council's memo to the committee, which relays the housing department's figures:

  • How the city got here: the buildings were part of 15 "cluster" sites a private owner rented to the Department of Homeless Services as family shelters. A nonprofit, Neighborhood Renewal Housing Development Fund Corp., bought them with city financing on June 23, 2021, signed a 60-year regulatory agreement capping rents at or below 60% of area median income, and gave existing residents rent-stabilized leases.
  • The condition: the buildings carry 337 Class A, 1,188 Class B and 541 Class C housing code violations, 2,066 in all. HPD says all will be resolved in the rehabilitation.
  • The work: gut renovations including asbestos and lead removal, new roofs, facade and structural repairs, full kitchen and bathroom replacements, new wiring and plumbing, and electric cooking, heat and hot water.
  • The new owner: at the construction closing, title moves to a company controlled by Fordham Bedford Housing Corp., a nonprofit founded in 1980 that the memo says oversees 112 buildings with more than 3,500 apartments. Merchants Bank and HPD are the lenders.
  • The tax break: two full exemptions. One is retroactive to June 2021 and runs up to six years, worth about $2.48 million. The other starts at the new owner's closing and runs 40 years, with a cumulative value of about $60 million and a present value of about $16.1 million, or $100,173 per apartment. The storefronts stay taxable, except one to be used for tenant social services.

The memo says the buildings have received no tax exemption since 2021 and that approving one "will reduce closing costs and decrease the amount of City Capital subsidy required." Of the 161 apartments, 97 are listed as existing homeless units, with future rents set at CityFHEPS voucher levels, and 32 are vacant and would be rented to households earning up to 50% or 60% of area median income.

160-159 Realty (Washington Heights)

The second request, LU 160, covers two five-story walk-ups built in the early 1900s with 32 apartments, all rent-stabilized and occupied, in District 10. According to the Council's memo:

  • The city took the buildings in a 2001 tax foreclosure and transferred them in 2002 and 2004. The owner later fell into "sustained financial distress," and Brooklyn Affordable Housing LLC, which has managed them since 2023, is the proposed new sponsor.
  • Repairs would go through HPD's Participation Loan Program. The buildings have 61 open code violations, 27 of them Class C.
  • A 40-year regulatory agreement would set rents for six apartments at 40% of area median income, two at 60% and 23 at 75%, with at least five set aside for homeless referrals. Current average rents run from $1,328 to $1,521 a month.
  • The 40-year exemption is valued at about $14 million in total, a present value of about $3.9 million.

What's next

The committee, chaired by Linda Lee, meets at 11 a.m. It also votes on higher budgets for eight business improvement districts, which we covered here, and a resolution changing which groups receive Council discretionary funds. Items it approves can go to the full Council at the 1:30 p.m. stated meeting. Agenda and documents are on the meeting page.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime