On My Block · NYC Politics

TransportationLegislation

The Council's e-bike package is pushed to December at the earliest. Here is where the Class 3 ban and the trade-in bill stand

Streetsblog reports the bills from the Sept. 30 hearing will wait while sponsors meet with delivery worker groups. The ban on selling Class 3 e-bikes has 30 Council sponsors. All 24 items heard that day are still in committee, 47 days later.

The Council's package of e-bike bills will not get a vote before December, multiple Council sources told Streetsblog on Monday. The delay gives sponsors time to revise their proposals after delivery worker groups and the transit working group of the city's Democratic Socialists of America chapter pushed for worker protections to be part of any new rules.

A Council spokesperson told Streetsblog the package is expected to pass in the coming months and that the Council has consulted a wide range of groups, including Los Deliveristas Unidos.

Why it matters to residents: the bills would change which e-bikes can be sold and ridden in the city. Most of the city's app delivery workers ride e-bikes, and the faster Class 3 models are the ones they tend to use.

Where the bills stand

Speaker Julie Menin's e-bike hearing on Sept. 30 was a joint meeting of the Transportation, Consumer and Worker Protection and Public Safety committees (meeting page). Our records show 24 items on its agenda: 23 bills and resolutions and the oversight topic. Every bill was laid over. None has had a vote.

The bills Streetsblog says matter most to delivery workers:

  • Int. 244, from Crystal Hudson, would ban the sale and rental of Class 3 e-bikes. It has 30 Council sponsors, with the Manhattan borough president. Streetsblog reported that both the DSA group and Los Deliveristas Unidos support it.
  • Int. 1110, also from Hudson, would ban riding Class 3 e-bikes. It was heard Sept. 30 before it was formally introduced on Oct. 8, and has 12 sponsors. Hudson told Streetsblog the ban would not take effect for three years. Streetsblog reported it would let police stop riders suspected of using one, which the DSA group says could mean more police encounters.
  • Int. 985, from Shaun Abreu, would set up a trade-in program for Class 3 bikes. It was amended at the hearing. Streetsblog reported it would offer new bikes or vouchers to 10,000 delivery workers; a 2025 city pilot traded in bikes for about 400 workers at a cost of about $2 million.

Other bills in the package include:

  • Int. 110, from Selvena N. Brooks-Powers, on devices used for commercial delivery, with 11 sponsors;
  • Int. 986, from Abreu, on testing e-bikes' power with dynamometers;
  • Int. 1102, from Abreu, on sidewalk-riding detection technology on e-bikes and e-scooters;
  • Int. 1052, from Vickie Paladino, on reporting e-bike and e-scooter crash data;
  • Res. 43, from Gale A. Brewer, backing a state bill to register commercial e-bikes.

What the groups want

Ligia Guallpa, executive director of Los Deliveristas Unidos, said putting enforcement and bans ahead of safe bike infrastructure is "deeply misguided," Streetsblog reported. The DSA group also argued that the Council should not pass rules app companies could use to justify deactivating workers while the city is defending its law against unfair deactivations in court.

Hudson told Streetsblog she has asked for a meeting with the administration, the Speaker's office, sponsors and delivery worker representatives, and hopes the package moves only after it.

What's next

  • The bills need committee votes. As of Monday, the Transportation Committee's two December meetings on our calendar, Dec. 2 on the Citi Bike contract and Dec. 15 on street takeovers, do not list them.
  • Separately, battery safety bills get a hearing Friday, Nov. 20 (our story).

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime