Nine days after Election Day, the Board of Elections still hasn't updated the count in the city's three closest Assembly races
At 10:35 a.m. Thursday the board's unofficial results still dated from 12:42 a.m. on Nov. 4. Military and overseas ballots have until Monday. Here is how many affidavit and absentee ballots the same three districts counted in 2024, for scale.
When we checked at 10:35 a.m. Thursday, Nov. 12, the Board of Elections' unofficial results for Assembly Districts 23, 49 and 63 still read "Information As Of: 2026-11-04," with times between 12:41 and 12:42 a.m. The numbers have not changed since election night.
Why it matters to residents: these three seats help set the size of each party's bloc when the Assembly convenes in January, and the Legislature writes the laws on rent, the MTA and city taxes.
This is a follow-up to our Wednesday story.
Where the counts stand
All figures are the board's unofficial election-night results. They do not include affidavit ballots or mail ballots counted after Oct. 30. We are not calling any of these races.
Advertisement
- District 49 (southern Brooklyn): Joyce Xiaoqiong Xie, the Democrat, 7,791 (52.81%); Assembly Member Lester Chang, the Republican, 6,930 on two lines (46.98%). Gap: 861, with 99% of scanners reporting.
- District 63 (Staten Island): Assembly Member Sam Pirozzolo, the Republican, 18,322 on two lines (51.80%); Matthew Mobilia, the Democrat, 17,009 (48.09%). Gap: 1,313, with 98.53% of scanners reporting.
- District 23 (the Rockaways, Broad Channel, Howard Beach and part of Ozone Park): Pesach Osina, the Democrat, 17,863 on two lines (51.92%); Thomas P. Sullivan, the Republican, 16,492 on three lines (47.94%). Gap: 1,371, with 97.1% of scanners reporting.
What hasn't been counted
Absentee and early mail ballots had to arrive by Tuesday, Nov. 10. Military and overseas ballots postmarked by Election Day can arrive through Monday, Nov. 16, the board's canvass page says. The board also has to rule on affidavit ballots, which voters fill out at poll sites when their registration can't be confirmed; many are found invalid.
The board says its mail ballot recaps are updated each Tuesday at close of business. On Thursday morning the page still linked the Nov. 3 reports, not a Nov. 10 update.
For scale: the 2024 counts in the same districts
The board's certified 2024 results for these seats, a presidential year with heavier turnout, show how many ballots came from each source:
- District 23: 1,390 affidavit ballots and 4,174 absentee or military ballots, out of 48,846 ballots (Queens recap).
- District 49: 717 affidavit and 1,993 absentee or military, out of 23,510 (Brooklyn recap).
- District 63: 994 affidavit and 4,810 absentee or military, out of 52,958.
Those figures are not a forecast. Most of this year's mail ballots were already scanned into the election-night totals, and the counted affidavit ballots split among candidates. The 2024 reports were printed for certification on Nov. 26 for Staten Island and Dec. 3 for Brooklyn and Queens, which gives a sense of how long the canvass can take.
Advertisement
Recounts
State law requires a full manual recount when the final margin is 20 votes or fewer, or half a percentage point or less. On election-night numbers, all three gaps are well above that. In 2022, Sullivan lost the District 23 seat by 15 votes after a count that took nearly two months, amNY reported.
What's next
The canvass runs daily, weekends included. We will update these counts when the board posts new numbers. The three districts overlap Council districts including Joann Ariola's, Selvena N. Brooks-Powers's, Kayla Santosuosso's, Susan Zhuang's and David M. Carr's.