On My Block · NYC Politics

EducationBudget

The city says 73% of classes now meet the class size law. Without a new way of counting, it would have fallen just short

Officials counted elementary art, music, science and gym classes for the first time. The target this year was 70%, and it rises to 80% next year. Here is what the schools chancellor and budget analysts told the Council in June.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration says the city met this year's benchmark under the state class size law, with about 73% of classes at or under the caps of 20 to 25 students, depending on grade, THE CITY reported Monday. Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels called it a "huge, huge step forward."

The figure includes elementary "cluster" classes, such as science, art, gym and music, counted for the first time this year. Without them the rate was 69.5%, just short of the 70% target.

Why it matters to residents: the law, passed in Albany in 2022, requires every class in the city's public schools to meet the caps by the 2029-30 school year. How fast the city gets there affects hiring, school space and the city budget.

The numbers

According to THE CITY:

  • The state target this year was 70%, lowered from 80% after Albany gave the city a two-year extension. Next year the city must reach 80%.
  • Middle and high school "exam prep" courses were also counted for the first time. Officials did not define them or break out their compliance.
  • The city granted no exemptions this year, compared with about 10,000 last year.
  • About 1,900 teachers were hired with $244 million last spring, after about 3,700 the year before with roughly $400 million. Total teacher headcount dipped from about 69,900 to 69,400.
  • The poorest schools average 90% of classes under the caps, compared with 57% at the wealthiest. District 32 in Bushwick had the highest rate, 92%, and District 26 in northeast Queens the lowest, 56%.
  • Nearly 500 schools still lack the space to bring every class under the caps.

What the Council heard in June

  • June 8, Finance and Education (schools budget): Gale A. Brewer asked how many classes had been reduced (4:37:02). Samuels said the law is "not about reducing class size necessarily," because a class cut from 25 to 22 students still does not count if the cap is 20. A schools official said about a third of noncompliant classes were only one to three students over, and the share of classes six or more students over had fallen from 29% to 17% (4:38:02).
  • Same hearing: Shekar Krishnan asked whether the department was using the recommendations of the 2023 class size working group on finding space. Officials said they were looking at shared space in existing buildings and other non-capital options, along with the capital plan (5:10:23).
  • June 9, Finance: The Independent Budget Office told the committee that after Albany extended the deadline by two years, bonuses for up to 2,450 teachers whose classes exceeded the caps would cost an estimated $21 million more (1:12:14).

THE CITY reported that the bonus, up to $8,500 per teacher under a deal with the teachers union, continues next year, and principals can get up to $10,000.

Who oversees it at the Council

The Committee on Education is chaired by Eric Dinowitz. Its meetings this week are on school buses, Wednesday, and a vote on a dental care information bill, Thursday (agenda). Neither agenda lists class size.

What's next

  • The city must reach 80% next school year and 100% by 2029-30.
  • The Council negotiates the next schools budget in the spring, starting with preliminary budget hearings in March.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime