On My Block · NYC Politics

Fire SafetyLegislation

At the battery fire hearing, the administration backed faster store closures but opposed a ban on owning uncertified e-bikes. The Speaker pressed on a trade-in program that ended

FDNY Commissioner Lillian Bonsignore said the department supports higher penalties for sellers and the two-strikes sealing bill, but the consumer protection department opposes Int. 1189's possession ban over its effect on delivery workers. Officials said the city's battery trade-in pilot ran its two years and ended in 2025.

The City Council's joint hearing on residential fires and lithium-ion batteries ran nearly five hours on Friday, Nov. 20. Speaker Julie Menin opened by saying, "I asked for this emergency hearing because we are in an emergency" (9:52).

Why it matters to residents: the administration's answers point to which of the seven bills could move quickly, and which, like a ban on possessing uncertified e-bikes and batteries, face resistance that could reshape them before any vote.

This follows our Friday preview of the three bills added to the agenda.

Where the administration stands, bill by bill

Fire Commissioner Lillian Bonsignore testified for the FDNY, joined by officials from the housing and buildings departments (34:15). According to her testimony:

  • Int. 1189, James F. Gennaro's penalties bill: the FDNY supports higher penalties for retailers who sell or lease uncertified devices. But she said "criminalizing the individual person for possession of uncertified devices would have a significant impact on a large number of New Yorkers," and that enforcement would be "very challenging" because it is hard to tell whether a battery in use for years was ever certified (51:01). She said the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection "opposes this bill," citing unintended consequences that would fall most heavily on delivery workers (52:31).
  • Int. 1202, Susan Zhuang's sealing bill: both the FDNY and the consumer protection department would support letting the city seal a store after violations on two occasions instead of three (53:03).
  • Int. 1184, Chair Joann Ariola's enforcement plan: both agencies "look forward to working with the council" on it (49:00).
  • Int. 920, from Phil Wong: it would remove a fire code exemption that allows mobility devices to be stored and charged inside apartments. The department said it would have "a significant impact" on people who rely on the devices and that it is working with the Council on "the right balance" (48:30).
  • Int. 582, from Jennifer Gutiérrez: it would require businesses that use bikes to give riders fire-resistant charging containers. The FDNY said no product has a UL certification for that use and none it tested held up to a battery fire; it would favor the requirement once one exists (48:00).

Why a possession ban is hard to enforce

Asked whether there was a way to fix Int. 1189, a department official said the focus should be the point of sale. Certification is shown by an adhesive sticker, the official said, and once a battery leaves the store nothing requires the owner to keep it on (59:01). Officials also said their evidence shows battery fires happen "much more often" when devices are not charging than when they are (1:00:32).

Fewer inspections, fewer violations found

An FDNY official said the battery task force had done 471 inspections at businesses this year, issued 255 summonses and found eight locations that met the threshold for sealing (1:02:00). The Council's committee report counted 843 inspections in 2025.

Menin called it "very concerning" that inspections were running at about half of last year's pace while deaths and injuries rose (1:04:00). Officials answered that inspectors had been to 75% of the city's stores more than once and are finding fewer violations because stores are complying, and that aging batteries bought before the city's rules took effect are likely driving fires.

The trade-in program

Menin asked why the city stopped its program swapping unsafe e-bikes and batteries for certified ones. The panel said it would have to defer to the Transportation Department, and she called that "really unacceptable" and asked for an answer by the end of the day (1:05:01). Later in the hearing an FDNY official said the program was a two-year pilot that concluded in 2025, "which is why it ended" (1:20:02). A council member responded that an agency does not need new legislation to renew a program that is working (1:20:30).

Bonsignore said in her opening that the department would like to see more programs to replace older uncertified devices and is "committed to working with our fellow City agencies to explore expanding trade in programs" (42:02).

The size of the old program differs by source. The Council's committee report says it exchanged more than 400 devices with $2 million; the Council's Friday release says the $2 million was committed to replace more than 200 batteries.

Charging cabinets

An FDNY fire prevention chief said six models of outdoor battery-charging cabinets are approved, at 22 sites across the city (1:22:30). Asked by Lincoln Restler, an official said reviewing an application for a battery-swap cabinet takes about eight weeks (2:04:31).

What's next

No votes were taken. Each bill would need a committee vote, which could bring amendments, before reaching the full Council. The Council's next stated meeting is Dec. 3.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime