On My Block · NYC Politics

LaborLegislation

Amazon tells New York shoppers the Delivery Protection Act 'could add up to $5 per order.' The bill's text contains no delivery charge

Pop-ups and a homepage banner ask customers to email their Council member against Int. 518. Speaker Julie Menin called the claim one that 'defies logic,' and the bill's sponsor took it to the Council floor Thursday. The bill still has no committee vote.

Amazon began showing New York City customers pop-up notices and a homepage banner on Thursday, Nov. 19, warning that a City Council bill "could add up to $5 per order" and urging them to "contact your council member to oppose Intro 518," CNBC reported. Amazon told CNBC that 20,000 customers emailed Council members in the first six hours.

The bill is Int. 518, from Tiffany L. Cabán, which supporters call the Delivery Protection Act. It would require operators of last-mile delivery warehouses to be licensed by the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection.

Why it matters to residents: the fight is over who employs the drivers who bring packages to your door, and whether that changes what you pay. Amazon says it would; the Council says it would not.

This follows our Tuesday story on the bill's sponsors and status.

What Amazon says

According to CNBC, Amazon's notice says the bill would "likely mean slower and more expensive delivery for millions of customers in New York City," and that the company would "be forced to consider moving our operations outside of the city" if it passes. CNBC reported that the bill would require Amazon to directly employ the delivery workers it now reaches through contracted delivery companies, a model it has used since 2018. Amazon said the bill would put jobs at those companies "at risk without improving safety," and spokesperson Kelly Nantel told CNBC the notices were meant to be "transparent with our customers."

What the bill says

We found no per-order charge in the bill's summary or the Council's fiscal estimate. The estimate puts the license fee at $500 per business and projects about $75,000 a year in fees citywide. PIX11 reported that the bill does not require a delivery surcharge. The $5 figure is Amazon's projection of what the change would cost it, not a term of the bill.

The Council's response

Speaker Julie Menin said Amazon's price claim "defies logic" and that "we are crafting legislation that regulates Amazon and protects workers, without impacting prices or jobs," CNBC reported. PIX11 reported that she called the campaign "a cynical ploy to trick New Yorkers."

Cabán raised it at Thursday afternoon's stated meeting. She called the pop-up "corporate bullying and corporate greed," said a $500 license fee every other year "in no way" amounts to $5 per order, and told members "we're not going to be bullied" (1:23:17).

Mayor Zohran Mamdani endorsed the bill in August, CNBC reported, saying the subcontractor model "leaves workers vulnerable and corporations free to avoid accountability."

Where it stands

  • Our records list 34 Council members as sponsors, including Cabán, plus Public Advocate Jumaane Williams and the Brooklyn and Manhattan borough presidents. A majority of the 51 members is 26; overriding a veto takes 34.
  • The bill was heard by the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection on April 9 and laid over. It has had no committee vote.
  • Menin's staff is drafting changes, as we reported Tuesday; an amended version would appear in our records as Int. 518-A.
  • Business and logistics groups have warned they may sue if it passes, CNBC reported.

The Council's remaining stated meetings this year are Dec. 3 and Dec. 17.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime